Forbes Burton  →  Free Resources  →  Advice & Insights  →  How a Shareholder Disagreement Can Derail SMEs

How a Shareholder Disagreement Can Derail SMEs

hands pointing and gesticulating to portray a shareholder disagreement

A shareholder disagreement can be one of the single most damaging things to a small business. Without clarity and a solid foundation, companies can quickly lose steam and find themselves in trouble.

As specialists in both resolving shareholder disagreements and helping businesses to avoid closure, we’ve seen first-hand just how damaging trouble at the top of the pyramid can be for a small company.

While it can seem that a disagreement between shareholders can be fairly benign, we’ve put together a list of red flags to look out for to allow you to nip such issues in the bud before they have chance to escalate. These are based around the assumption that the dispute has arisen from one party looking to sell their shares, as this tends to more be the case more often than not.

 

Spooked staff

It only takes one member of staff to hear a whisper or even pick up on disgruntled body language to set the rumour mill in motion. If there’s even just a sniff of anybody selling up or becoming frustrated, it can unsettle workers very easily.

Everyone wants job security. People plan their lives around their jobs, whether that be moving closer to cut down on a commute or taking out car loans or mortgages that this particular job allows them to pay for. With so much at stake, any degree of uncertainty is met with fear and possibly looking for another (safer) job elsewhere.

In the middle of a dispute between shareholders, the last thing you’d need is a mass exodus of experienced staff that need replacing. We saw this exact scenario play out with a window fabrication company whose directors’ falling out had been noticed by the rest of the staff. Almost half of their workforce left within the following six months, leaving them struggling to honour contracts and source replacements. Luckily, they had come to us in time to allow us to steady the ship and negotiate a deal that both parties were happy with.

 

Lack of direction

With uncertainty at the top, other long-term plans tend to get put on hold. It’s common to see businesses stagnate somewhat while a shareholder disagreement rumbles on over months or even years. Without an independent valuation, such as those we offer, negotiations can resemble a war of attrition instead, waiting out the other party until they cave to the other’s valuation. As you might expect, this can take a significant amount of time and provides the shakiest of foundations for negotiations to be built upon.

Businesses that don’t keep up with competition often get left behind, and if growth plans are stalled because there are doubts over whether appropriate funds can be diverted to them if shares need to be bought back.

Equally, there may be consternation that the changes proposed could alter the value of the company, leading one party to block plans. Either way, it’s rare to see companies with ownership issues make inroads with growth strategies at the same time.

 

Breakdown in trust

In certain ownership scenarios, such as a 50/50 split, neither shareholder can outvote the other. This means that once trust has eroded and left ill will between the warring parties it becomes difficult to get anything done. Things like approving contracts, securing funding or hiring staff suddenly become almost impossible.

With larger concerns grinding to a halt, clients and suppliers can be lost, and day-to-day operations can eventually be affected.

 

Financial arguments

During a dispute over business value, it’s inevitable that at least one side will feel like they’re either not being offered enough or believe that they’re being asked for too much.

This quickly spills into other financial decisions within the company. We’ve seen legal battles that have lasted so long that they’ve cost huge amounts of money.

Things can quickly turn ugly when money is involved and one party thinks they’re being taken advantage of.

 

Case study:

One the companies that sought help from us had a majority shareholder that was annoyed at the amount of money the departing shareholder wanted. This director retaliated by raising their own salary to avoid declaring dividends.

Once the minority shareholder found out about this, tensions escalated even further to the point that by the time they came to us for help, the company was practically at a standstill.

We quickly arranged a non-biased independent valuation that both parties agreed to abide to beforehand. After that was in place, we were able to arrange a suitable payment structure that allowed the company to carry on trading comfortably, while the departing shareholder received a total fee that they were happy with too.

 

Need help navigating a shareholder disagreement?

Forbes Burton provides shareholder dispute resolution services that offer independent valuations and binding agreements that all parties are happy with.

Shareholder disputes can have a detrimental effect on your business if allowed to trundle on for too long. Speak to one of our advisors today on 0800 060 8446 or email advice@forbesburton.com to get everything sorted promptly and professionally.

 

 

Author

  • Rick has over 30 years' worth of experience of advising companies across a range of sectors.

    He specialises in mergers, acquisitions and business sales, and is an active business investor himself. His insights on the world of business and M&As have meant that he's featured in countless news outlets, such as The Independent, The Telegraph, Sky News, The Mirror and The Daily Mail.

Free Confidential Advice And Help For Company Directors

Need some advice? Get in touch using the form below or by calling us on
0800 975 0380

Trustpilot Reviews

Related Articles

two businessmen discussing a 3d pie chart

My Business Partner Wants to Sell Their Shares

Read Article →

Why an Independent Business Valuation is Crucial in Shareholder Disputes

Read Article →

We're here for you.

As a dedicated team of Advisers and Consultants our aim is to help you fix the issues and solve the problems within your business.

Find out more →
ladies with arms crossed in black and white
forbes burton logo

For free confidential advice, get in touch today.

Call us for free (mobiles and landlines)

0800 975 0380
advice@forbesburton.com

Get Free Confidential Advice

London Office
Silverstream House
45 Fitzroy Street, Fitzrovia
London, W1T 6EB
United Kingdom

Birmingham Office
Office 1, Izabella House,
24-26 Regent Place,
City Centre,
Birmingham, B1 3NJ
United Kingdom

Manchester Office
First Floor, Swan Buildings,
20 Swan Street,
Manchester, M4 5JW
United Kingdom

Bristol Office
Henleaze House,
13 Harbury Road,
Henleaze, Bristol,
BS9 4PN
United Kingdom

Grimsby Office
Innovation Centre,
Innovation Way, Europarc,
DN37 9TT
United Kingdom